Casey Jones Grill Reviews
Submitted by RazzleDazzle Sanfilippo on 09/02/2022
RazzleDazzle Sanfilippo 5 stars rating.
This place is amazzzzing. I make custom clothes and jewelry, this spot has the perfect size tables for me to put in some work while I socialize. Chris the bartender is FIRE, great people, awesome food and good times all around!!
LaurieLu 5 stars rating.
LOVE this place. Great people and the food is fabulous. Free Comedy night every third Saturday. It is like CHEERS, they remember you. Armando great chef and loves to share his cooking skills with all.
Submitted by Laurielu on 09/20/2022
Zimskygirls (Zimskygirls) 1 stars rating.
I've been to this establishment many times. There are two bartenders that stand out in a good way. They both have beards and are super cool! My experience this evening however was atrocious. I was sitting at the bar top, having just received my pint of beer, when the gentleman two spots left takes a phone call. After a couple of minutes I was sure he would walk away to take the call a bit more privately.
Instead I heard a lengthy conversation about his medications, surgery prep, etc, meanwhile being unable to hear the person directly to my right. Once he was off the phone I politely asked him if I could ask him a question. I said: "Why did you not feel the need to step away to take that phone call?" I was not rude, snarky or anything of the sort. Keep in mind I've had maybe half my beer. He apologized and said that he didn't expect it to take that long, etc.
It would have been done at that point, right? No, instead, the very large gentleman immediately to my left decides to tell me I need to keep my mouth shut and mind my f@$&?! business. I told him that I found it inappropriate for him to be speaking to me that way. At that time a bartender, Samantha, was walking towards us asking how everything was. I explained that the man had began cursing at me for asking the man to his left a question. She went on to say, "Well see we have regulars here" and I interrupted her by saying " I don't give a s$&@! Like are we being serious, am I on a prank show?
Are we seriously excusing a man from speaking t to a woman that way? Like what are we talking about. I say to the woman that I've been nothing but calm when speaking with the other gentleman and instead I'm told "we have regulars". So regulars are allowed to curse at other patrons. Fantastic, thank you Samantha. At this point I finished my beverage and left.
Minutes later I received a message from my partner stating that Samantha text, instead of whispering, to these two apparent brother, probably apologizing to them for them to only talk about it in front of my partner. She then had the audacity to apologize to my partner. Absolutely rude, disgusting, and appalling.
Submitted by Zimskygirls (zimskygirls) on 09/12/2022
Alan Tripp 5 stars rating.
Wow food and off track horse betting what a combo. If you are a Green Bay fan well they are welcoming for that too. Friendly quick service. The burger was great hitting just the spot I was looking to fill for lunch. Lots of seating. Recommended.
Submitted by Alan Tripp on 09/03/2022
Tonia 5 stars rating.
They have good wings and the prices ate very reasonable. This is a cool low key place to have drinks. If you don't want to spend a lot of money and don't want to dress up.
Submitted by Tonia on 08/14/2022
Clay Collins 5 stars rating.
It was our first time there and it was a great experience! Excellent prices and service, and the pool and darts area was super fun! We will definitely be back.
Submitted by Clay Collins on 08/08/2022
David 4 stars rating.
Casey Jones always seems to do good business around OTB in the back and the front seems to be hopping!
Staff seems friendly enough except for the one guy standing behind the window at OTB younger guy.. I asked him how his chicken wings were cuz he was eating and he said I wouldn't know because people keep coming up and making bets ????????
I'd definitely go back ????????
Submitted by David on 06/28/2022
Marilyn Ragland 5 stars rating.
Really enjoyed all around food, prices, service, atmosphere and clean. We went at an off hour so enjoyed a low noise level. Do not know how it is at peak times. It was Taco Tuesday so great chicken fajita tacos on flour tortillas and house margaritas. Definitely going back.
Submitted by Marilyn Ragland on 05/18/2022
Gail Oleaga 5 stars rating.
Vanessa is an excellent server. She is very attentive and pleasant too! She made my visit very enjoyable.
Submitted by Gail Oleaga on 12/15/2021
Luke Larson 5 stars rating.
Is saying that this place was a huge surprise a compliment? I sure hope so. Walked in right as they opened and were the first customers. Huge place and wall to wall Packers memorabilia and trains hanging from the ceiling. Very cool. The compliments continue. Our bartender Samantha was great and suggested the lemon chicken. The suggestion was spot on and the chicken and couscous was incredible. Can not say a negative thing about this place. ????????????????
Submitted by Luke Larson on 11/15/2021
