Mellow Mushroom Phoenix Reviews
Submitted by George on 09/17/2022
George 2 stars rating.
Let me Begin by saying I used to love mellow mushroom in Atlanta in the 1980s. As far as Pizza goes this is not a place I would ever return to for a pizza or calzone. I gave it two stars only because the bar had some great beers on tap.
Being from New Jersey and New York with the fortunate experience of living in Italy I'm a fan of traditional Italian pizza. This is not in that category.
I ordered a mushroom pizza and I deliberately ask the waiter to make sure that the crust was not burnt. He indicated that the pizzas are cooked for 7 minutes in some sort of automated oven. Well sure enough the pizza came with the entire bottom of the crust burnt. When he came over to the table he didn't ask if we enjoyed the pizza but rather stated the pizzas wonderful isn't it? And I indicated to him that the pizza was burnt. He offered to make a free small pizza which I declined because if it stays in the oven for the same automated 7 minutes it would come out the same.
The pizza was very oily and probably the worst part was the dough was very very dry.
We also ordered a calzone to sample. This was not burnt but it was the same dry dough. The ingredients were definitely fresh and quite good but I'm not sure what the point is if the dough is not very good.
The atmosphere of the restaurant when you first walk in looks very cool and fun. However it is so loud from people's talking and the high ceilings with probably a metal or concrete roof that it's impossible to have a conversation with your table mates.
As mentioned the bar had a great selection of beers, but this is not a place to have a beer and talk with a friend because as stated it's just too loud in the restaurant.
A huge disappointment for pizza place that used to be great when it was simple. I definitely would not return nor recommend this to anyone.
Bizzy Mommee 4 stars rating.
Thursday evening with family… not too busy. Got a table asap. Ordered ???? bites, ????, hot wings and cocktails. I really enjoyed the baked wings. Being baked really made the meat fall off the bones. Yum! ???? The pizza wasn’t a favorite. Nothing wrong with it, just not my style. Chewy crust like a pretzel… I’d go back for the wings.
Submitted by Bizzy Mommee on 08/15/2022
Gray Jedi 4 stars rating.
Two pies, four drinks and two appetizers. Roughing $95. The food was great the service was good. The aura and ambiance of the location has a nice vibe.
Submitted by Gray Jedi on 07/30/2022
Yasumi Shiguematsu 5 stars rating.
Food is awesome, they have gluten free options also a lot of vegetarian dishes. I love their pizza bread, texture is perfect, flavors are on point, customer service is good. Sincerely this is the best pizza I've ever had.
First time I tried it, it was at their Tempe's location, but the food in this one was just as good.
Submitted by Yasumi Shiguematsu on 07/06/2022
Felicia Padilla 5 stars rating.
Best pizza place! The crispy crust on the end of my pizza was tasty and deliciously fresh. The cheese amount is generous along with the topping. The music and the atmosphere were a vibe! The service was friendly and the artichoke dip is to die for!
We order the Hawaiian Pizza
The calzone and Buffalo chicken ???? pizza! Not your ordinary pizza place ????
Submitted by Felicia Padilla on 05/26/2022
Jubilee Diming 3 stars rating.
Underwhelming experience! Used to come here often when I was pregnant for late night reverse happy hour that starts at 10pm. (Only plus of the evening!) Server was really weird about not being about to accept my husband's legal digitized gov. id that we've even used to board an airplane. I presented her with his physical id which luckily I had and she then left and came back and said she was still unable to serve him. We then asked for a manager where he let us know they were aware it was legal and legit but that they didn't accept it. Weird response but fair I guess it's yal business. We then strangely started being served by another server on the floor which was better cuz he was a way better server anyway. Manager then apologized and discounted the bill for the trouble. Not the best customer experience but I enjoyed the cheap drinks! ????????♀️????????♀️
Submitted by Jubilee Diming on 05/17/2022
Crisco Extras 5 stars rating.
First time tonight and the Customer Service deserves FIVE stars alone! Shawnie was great and so was the entire staff we encountered. Pizza is on point! We'll definitely be back.
Submitted by Crisco Extras on 02/19/2022
Jordan Cogsdill 4 stars rating.
Hadn't been here in ages and it's so much better than I remembered! We ordered the Merry Prankster and while it's not your traditional pizza, it was phenomenal! The way they make their dough allowa for the pizza to reheat great without getting rock hard.
We also ordered the cheese bread and wedge salad. The cheese bread was great, the cheese tasted fresh and the bread quality they used was awesome. The wedge salad was mediocre at best. They advertise an entire wedge, which is what you'd expect to get from a wedge salad but in reality it's just half. Plus the marinated tomatoes they add to it are over powering and take away from the wedge salad taste.
Submitted by Jordan Cogsdill on 02/08/2022
Sedona 5 stars rating.
Pizza was so good! Especially dough part! Little bit cheesy to me but satisfied enough! I would like to go again :)
Submitted by Sedona on 01/15/2022
Nathan Day 4 stars rating.
Great salads and pizza! Lots of toppings! The music is a little too loud for conversation on a date night, but it's great music and great food! Worth a visit
Submitted by Nathan Day on 10/22/2021
