Proper Pizza and Pasta Reviews
Submitted by Goldin Dollar on 07/21/2022
Goldin Dollar 5 stars rating.
This place has quickly become one of my favorite! The chicken Alfredo is GREAT, with nice pieces of chicken. The sauce is delicious ,I always ask for extra and the garlic bread knots are SOOO DELICIOUS!!! I haven’t tried many knots who could compete! You will be pleasantly surprised when you try them. THEY ARE WORTH IT! Good service here too!
Yanci Montes 5 stars rating.
Best Caprese Salad. Love their cheese pizza. Excellent customer service. Highly recommend this pizza place.
Submitted by Yanci Montes on 08/25/2022
Cur tis 5 stars rating.
I can't eat italian food back home ever again.
I'm from Utah and even big name italian sit downs do not taste this good. The pizza was good but the pasta was fantastic. I left wondering why it was so empty when I went. I can only hope and pray that an italian restaurant will match the quality provided by this pizza/pasta hybrid.
The staff were pretty good and nice too. Give them a raise.
Submitted by Cur Tis on 07/06/2022
Rhonda Chandler 5 stars rating.
Good food and kind people. We were in town for a surgery for my husband. We placed a dinner order for delivery via the Slice app. The order was made, picked up, but not delivered by the delivery company (door dash). I called and reordered. Proper Pizza and Patsy remade the order, and it was delivered. They included two freshly made cookies in my reorder. It wasn't their fault, but they accommodated me anyway. This is just great customer service.
Submitted by Rhonda Chandler on 06/12/2022
TJ White 5 stars rating.
Yoooooo the chicken pesto pasta is so good their rating should be 5 stars. Best I ever had! ❤️ I ate it so fast I was sad.
Submitted by Tj White on 05/20/2022
Fernando Brito 5 stars rating.
The pizza here is amazing! Even better, the service is top notch. It’s a smaller place so don’t expect full service but the guy at the counter was super friendly despite being super busy. The cook also came out and gave us our food. You can tell that this team works great together and value each other’s work. Love to see it!
Submitted by Fernando Brito on 05/14/2022
Stephen Lee 5 stars rating.
Probably as close as a NY pizza you will get in CA. A new king! There was another spot but this place is the best! Fast delivery as well!!! Loved it!!!
Submitted by Stephen Lee on 03/25/2022
sarahi arellano 5 stars rating.
This is the best pizza I've had. The pizza was so crispy, fresh and delicious. We were a group of 7 and got a few different pizzas they were all good. The garlic knots were outta this world. The restaurant was so clean and the service was amazing. I can't rave enough about this place. Every time I come to California I will be coming here.
Submitted by Sarahi Arellano on 03/16/2022
Jason S (Simchelin Guide) 5 stars rating.
They specialize in NY style pizza and it was really good! We got the Supreme pizza and it was good. We also got the Pesto Penne and That was AMAZING! All the dishes we ordered were rich and flavorful. Definitely coming back here again to try the Shrimp Scampi and the Carbonara Pizza. That's right Carbonara PIZZA
The parking lot is medium sized and no valet so it's free. But it can get packed on peak times.
Last but not least. The employees are so kind and helpful. Even the cooks and bakers are so kind enough to help out with things like getting a to-go box.
Submitted by Jason S (simchelin Guide) on 02/25/2022
Rafael 5 stars rating.
From NYC and this pizza and pasta are delicious every time I stop by here. Incredible recipe for their pastas that makes me come back. Staff are really friendly here and get the orders out pretty well. Very enjoyable that I brought my friends
Submitted by Rafael on 12/27/2021
