Brigantine Seafood Restaurant Reviews
Submitted by Matthew Alexander on 09/20/2022
Matthew Alexander 5 stars rating.
As Excellent as any of the other locations, maybe better. Order 1 of everything & share in a big group. Enjoy!
Mildred Fox 4 stars rating.
The food was great. The service started of excellent, but as the evening wore on, our server paid less ans less attention to us. At first we were very interested in having dessert, but after no one coming to check on us for at least fifteen minutes we decided against it. Natasha, next time, make sure you pay attention to all your tables.
Submitted by Mildred Fox on 09/21/2022
Elias Carbajal 5 stars rating.
This is a very lovely place. The food and service is stellar. Every bite was perfection to the fullest. I will be back again and soon. I recommend this place for anyone that wants to enjoy amazing seafood.
Submitted by Elias Carbajal on 08/27/2022
eric west 5 stars rating.
Had a wonderful experience at the Brigantine on Shelter Island. Even though it was a packed house on a Saturday evening, our server Rita was top notch. Ordered the lobster tacos and a surf & turf plate. Both were cooked perfectly. Plates were removed after each course, not pilling up like some let happen. A most excellent anniversary dinner, thank you Brigantine!
Submitted by Eric West on 08/07/2022
Leidi Schaumburg 5 stars rating.
Wonderful restaurant, everything impeccable. High quality service, beautiful and pleasant place. Suggestion order the starter of Octopus and for dessert the Creme Brullé you will not regret it????!
Submitted by Leidi Schaumburg on 07/23/2022
Kristina Baroni 5 stars rating.
Wow!! So good. We came here for mother's day brunch and they were so sweet and gave Mom a flower. Food was fantastic, service was great! We'll definitely come back to try the lunch and dinner menus!
Submitted by Kristina Baroni on 05/31/2022
Monique Hickson 5 stars rating.
Fantastic food, service and great bar vibe with lots of televisions. We had the Buffalo wings, Shrimp/Crab Louis salad and Shrimp Tacos. All of the food was delicious and our server Caitlin was awesome! We didn't quite make it for Happy Hour but I highly recommend getting there between 3-6pm for a great Happy Hour option! Cheers!
Submitted by Monique Hickson on 05/25/2022
YK Mitchell 5 stars rating.
I will start by saying great staff!!! My nephew decided to have his wedding rehearsal dinner here and they were very attentive, fast and friendly. There was a separate menu for our party and professionally done. I had the steak and although the steak itself lacked the right amount of seasoning, the elements that topped the steak and the bed of potatoes and sauce that it sat upon balanced it out perfectly (risky, yet well played.) The salmon was cooked just right and the flavors were good but not great. The wagyu burger was perfect and so were the scallops. My old fashioned was stronger than my liking but the Moscow mule was exceptional. Overall, it was a great experience along with a great atmosphere. I will be back.
Submitted by Yk Mitchell on 03/28/2022
Trey 5 stars rating.
This Brigantine is located just before the entrance to Shelter Island and though this location doesn’t have a view like their other restaurants the service and food was good. The brunch steak and eggs came out really good and the server provided excellent service. Will definitely come back again.
Submitted by Trey on 01/02/2022
Yo Av 3 stars rating.
Traditional seafood restaurant and dated decor. The food itself was average. The strong flavors of the seasoning and sauce masked the natural flavors of the food. The place was mostly empty around 11:30 and service was quick. The experience was fine but not special.
Submitted by Yo Av on 11/06/2021
