Paisan Pizzeria Reviews
Submitted by Patti Franklin on 06/22/2022
Patti Franklin 5 stars rating.
Great pizza, live music, bar next door and a pool. What more do you want?
PatRJ B 5 stars rating.
Most delicious pizza I've had ????????????????
Submitted by Patrj B on 07/12/2022
JoAnne Miranda 1 stars rating.
Only able to order delivery—no carryout option. Paid delivery fee and added additional item to get to minimum $ for delivery…received the wrong pizza. They don’t answer the phone when they’re closed (but still delivering). Will update if the refund I was promised actually happens.
Submitted by Joanne Miranda on 07/05/2022
Cinzia Ianniciello Anderson 5 stars rating.
Actually not bad at all! Expected it to be the "typical" resort fast food, but I was pleasantly surprised. We got the Margherita pizza and the caprese sandwich. Both delicious! Pizza had a nice, crispy crust and was not drenched in tomato sauce. Yummy fresh ingredients, fresh mozzarella cheese. Caprese sandwich had a great balsamic vinaigrette and thickly sliced tomatoes and mozzarella. We went back twice :) highly recommend!
Submitted by Cinzia Ianniciello Anderson on 06/13/2022
Faith Ferrer 2 stars rating.
I did not ever experience paisan pizzeria like this. It was the worst experience that I ever had with them, after being there a few times. I ordered Parmesan chicken sandwich and a meatball sub sandwich with garlic knots. The food took a long time to get to us. Also, the prices was kind of high for what what I ordered. The sandwiches were edible to someone who was really hungry. The garlic knots were high, I only received a few when I asked for a large. I did not eat them because I spit it once I tasted it. It was hard, crusty and didn't even have a gracias flavour. The homemade potato chips were cold and tasted disgusting. I threw them away. But, the food was cold and I could tell it was reheated and straight out of a box. It was not homemade. I asked for extra meatballs for my child and the meatballs did not come with any sauce. I would not recommend going here. Please save your money.
Submitted by Faith Ferrer on 06/04/2022
Dean Boturla 1 stars rating.
Because it was Late ,after 9:00 and it was Right next to a Alcohol stand ,We had Two large pies.On a Scale of thru 10 I would give it a 1.Flop city No under carage.Lame Pizza.
In fact the Worse Pizza EVER !!!
After 4 Jack n Cokes,It was EDIBLE !!! ????
Submitted by Dean Boturla on 05/02/2022
Karen Bordonaro 1 stars rating.
The pizza was ok, the chicken wings had no taste and the BBQ sauce was missing. The salad came with no dressings that we asked for so we couldn’t eat them. Probably won’t e ordering from them again.
Submitted by Karen Bordonaro on 05/01/2022
Ramon “Domingo” De Los Santos 5 stars rating.
This pizza restaurant sorprised me inside the complex of my timeshare Holiday inn club vacations it's located by the pool it can't get better than that the pizza ????taste delicious ???? and the barbecue wins the same to make it even better they have outdoors games and kid activities while you wait for your food but it doesn't end yet they make the pool are more because they have a DJ playing good music for everyone ????
Submitted by Ramon “domingo” De Los Santos on 03/30/2022
Evan Bray 5 stars rating.
Ordered a pizza from here. Did not expect much, but the pizza was amazing! I don't usually eat the crust because it is dry and hard, but this crust was fluffy and warm, like eating Nan. Absolutely delicious and would recommend it to everyone!
Submitted by Evan Bray on 06/11/2021
Bill Martin 5 stars rating.
We stayed at Orange Lake from June 28 to July 3rd this year (2020). We checked in exactly one month after they reopened following the nationwide shutdown due to the Coronavirus. Like everything else in the world they were at reduced capacity for everything on site. Paisan Pizzeria was one of the only places open serving food. Fortunately it's one of the best pizzas I've ever had. I had three different pizzas over our five night stay and loved each one. My wife ordered a meatball sub once too which was delicious.
Submitted by Bill Martin on 10/04/2020
