My Pi Pizza Reviews
Submitted by Lola Marmolejo on 07/24/2022
Lola Marmolejo 5 stars rating.
Excellent, fresh toppings flavors were poppin . This was my first time having Chicago style pizza and it was delicious. Worth the drive from Milwaukee
Holbertclan 5 stars rating.
My first time...the thin is absolutely delicious...I am not a fan of bread, it was as if I was eating only toppings. Super delish
Submitted by Holbertclan on 09/01/2022
brendan daley 5 stars rating.
I am a lifelong chicagoan, and my pi is the best deep dish in the city, bar none.
Each aspect of the pizza is executed to perfection—the sauce is bursting with flavor; the crust is crisp and buttery throughout; the meat toppings are juicy, and the veggie toppings are soft-yet-firm; and the bottom layer of cheese subtly complements the rest of the pizza.
Submitted by Brendan Daley on 08/20/2022
Kirsten Potter 5 stars rating.
This was SO GOOD. My Husband and Brother both loved the pizza, as did I! The vegan pizza is fantastic so if you’re wanting to experience Chicago deep dish you’re in good hands. The person at the counter was very nice and patient with us as well. This pizza cured our souls after a long weekend of being busy and traveling from Cincinnati :)
Submitted by Kirsten Potter on 08/16/2022
Marco Barry 5 stars rating.
Vegan cheese deep dish was soooo good! Flew back to Nashville with it and it was still amazing after being in the car, going through two airports, and the flight. Will definitely be back next time we’re in town. Also, the staff were really friendly and welcoming. The location was great, too.
Submitted by Marco Barry on 08/12/2022
Story Cox 3 stars rating.
Important to note, this place is take out only! They have a couple picnic tables outside but there is no indoor seating. As vegans, we really appreciated that they provided non-dairy cheese, but I just didn't love the pizza. It just didn't seem that high quality to us.
Submitted by Story Cox on 07/20/2022
Tom K 4 stars rating.
Actually quite good.
Spinach, sausage and garlic deep dish pizza. It had a good strong flavor, no blandness.
I’m used to a lot of cheese in stuffed pizza, but this isn’t stuffed. My friend would’ve preferred more cheese though.
I picked up the pizza (after driving through crazy traffic) and the building is quite small in a strip mall with not too many and tiny parking spots.
The person that rang me up was nice. I don’t think you can sit inside, or maybe i just went to the pickup door/window.
When i paid it automatically asked for a tip. I clicked none. I don’t like when they set it up asking you for tip for stuff we never used to tip for. I mean, companies please pay your people properly and stop shifting out to tips.
Submitted by Tom K on 07/08/2022
Jennifer Eatchel 5 stars rating.
We didn't have a lot of time passing through Chicago, but definitely wanted to experience authentic deep dish pizza. We stopped at My Pi based on Google reviews, and our expectations were completely exceeded! Everything was perfect. The crust was tasty, and somehow soft *and* crisp. The toppings were fresh and flavorful. The cheese was perfectly melty without scorching our mouths. And the sauce. Oh! The sauce! Is there an Italian Nonna in the kitchen making it? It sure tasted like it! If I could give My Pi 10 stars I would!
Submitted by Jennifer Eatchel on 07/03/2022
Sunne Clarke 5 stars rating.
They have the best stuffed vegan pizza in the US! I've been everywhere and tried every pizza there is. This is hands down the best!
Submitted by Sunne Clarke on 07/01/2022
Haley Miller 5 stars rating.
Love the vegan menu. We got the deep dish vegan sausage special. The ladies working there were very nice to us too. Thank you!! We will be back to try the garlic bread!
Submitted by Haley Miller on 06/13/2022
Hope B 5 stars rating.
I'm such a huge fan of the spinach souffle pizza! It's so unique and such an amazing blend of the spinach cheese and amazing sauce. I've been going to My Pi for years.
It's mostly takeout but they do have some nice picnic tables outside you could eat at if the weather is nice
Submitted by Hope B on 06/08/2022
Russell Knight 5 stars rating.
Got a small cheese pizza and a focaccia chicken sandwich. They threw in a cookie and a brownie. Nice touch. We are outside in the shade.
Submitted by Russell Knight on 05/29/2022
Peter Lio 5 stars rating.
Outstanding and very unique! I got the stuffed spinach soufflé and I can’t stop thinking about it! This is a TOP Chicago pizza spot and a must try!
Submitted by Peter Lio on 04/24/2022
Caroline Amodeo 5 stars rating.
Got a small deep dish pizza with vegan cheese but pepperoni (dairy allergy) and the vegan garlic bread. It was fantastic. 10/10 would recommend. Be sure to call ahead for pick up (we ordered at the window and had to wait awhile).
Submitted by Caroline Amodeo on 03/31/2022
Alex 4 stars rating.
I ordered My Pi's deep dish pizzas via nationwide Goldbelly delivery. Can't get deep dish pizzas like this in NYC. The pizzas arrived fully frozen, intact, and on time.
Their pizza's can be compared to the others I've had in the past from Chicago (Lou Malnati's, Pequod's, Bartolini's, etc.), however, My Pi's aren't quite as "deep" and heavy as the other's I've mentioned. Still large enough to feed 3-4 people easily, though.
Their sauce flavor isn't as robust and flavorful as the others, but I was impressed by the amount of toppings on each pie. Cheese was super gooey, as a pie like this should be!
Overall, a solid deep dish pie experience considering it came from half way across the country!
Submitted by Alex on 02/07/2022
Ashley Tassin 5 stars rating.
Pizza is my favorite food. This was the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. Very vegan friendly restaurant. I got the small pepperoni deep dish and my friend got a vegan pizza and vegan garlic bread. All very good. Employees were very nice. Refilled our waters many times and let us use bathroom. No indoor seating but there are picnic tables outside. Great place. Will come back next time I’m in Chicago. THANKS!!!!
Submitted by Ashley Tassin on 10/12/2021
Ashley Lynn Kelly 5 stars rating.
Wonderful handmade pizza. They are expensive but I have never held a pizza so heavy! Thank you for having vegan cheese so we could experience
Submitted by Ashley Lynn Kelly on 05/28/2021
Dude 4 stars rating.
In A Nutshell:
-My Pi Pizza is a true Chicago deep dish pizza, which you can order & have it delivered nationwide.
-Enjoyed it during the Super Bowl.
-The pizza comes w/ very specific instructions to ensure the pizza comes out perfect.
-The ingredients are second-to-none using premium everything to include Wisconsin cheese!
Overall, this is pizza worth ordering no matter where you are!
Submitted by Dude on 02/09/2021
Enan Del Rio 4 stars rating.
The pizza was very good, had a crispy crust, fresh topping, good sauce, but I gave this 4 stars instead of 5 stars as this was supposed to be a stuffed pizza and seemed a little too thin to be called stuffed, seemed more like a pan pizza thickness. Other than that this as a great pizza.
Submitted by Enan Del Rio on 02/26/2020
