Nancys Pizzeria Reviews
Submitted by Christopher Gorrie on 08/02/2020
Christopher Gorrie 4 stars rating.
Nancy’s makes some really delicious pizza. I got a take-out order for a small Rocco’s Party. Although there was a slight delay in me receiving the order, the staff was nice about it and gave me a free soda. The pizza itself was really tasty. The sausage was top notch. It was crispy, but not burnt. It was also not overly greasy. The restaurant itself is beautiful, really nice booths and decor. I took one star off of this review just because of the price. I don’t live in Chicago so maybe food is generally more expensive here, but I though upwards of $20 for a small pizza was a bit expensive. (The pizza, however, could feed two people.)
Farhad Hossain Masum 5 stars rating.
Great experience! Highly recommended.
The meatball sliders were the best among the other appetizers we tried. Definitely try those little balls of happiness. It was very tasty, not bland at all. It was rich, buttery. Fried onion rings were very good too. Chicken wings were alright.
Now, let's come to the deep dish pizza. This is the second deep dish pizza I tried, and the first one I liked. There were great flavors. The crust was perfect, not too dry, not too mushy. Since my experience (at Giordano's) was not good, I was skeptic. But Nancy's didn't disappoint.
Drinks were very good too. We tried 4 different cocktails. First three were perfect. On the 4th one, something funny happened. One of us took a sip, found it was butter, and made a face. The bartender saw it, came running, and asked what was wrong with it. He said, he can give us a new one but we wanted to just add some lime juice to it. I liked the fact that they cared about the quality of their items and their customer's satisfaction.
Will definitely come here again to try other items but I know my appetizer. Yes, the meatballs!
Submitted by Farhad Hossain Masum on 09/09/2022
Ebony H. 5 stars rating.
The best thin crust pizza hands down. I haven’t tried the deep dish but I will next time. The customer service was great as well.
Submitted by Ebony H. on 08/30/2022
Brisa Barraza 4 stars rating.
Pizza 10/10
Wings 10/10
Bread sticks 10/10
Ordered through 3rd Party delivery service, Although one food item was missed, Mariana the manager was able to correct the issue. She was very professional over the phone and provided excellent customer service. Definitely driving back to eat delicious pizza and wings.
Submitted by Brisa Barraza on 08/22/2022
Sabrina Sharma 5 stars rating.
Their classic thin crust pizza is my absolute favorite!! I’ve placed multiple delivery orders at this location and the food is always hot, fresh and delicious! I have also tried their breadsticks (served with marinara sauce) and waffle fries, which were pretty good too. Overall, I’d definitely recommend giving this restaurant a try!
Submitted by Sabrina Sharma on 08/19/2022
Nick Afzall 5 stars rating.
Excellent food and phenomenal service! Adam was very personable and gave great recommendations. Highly recommend the pesto fries as a side.
Submitted by Nick Afzall on 08/14/2022
Nick Oakley 5 stars rating.
What can I say. My first experience of authentic deep dish Chicago pizza and it was epic. Nothing could have prepared me for this. It was amazing.
Submitted by Nick Oakley on 07/18/2022
Ann K 5 stars rating.
This is the BEST pizza spot in the city! I used to be a Homerun Inn girl, but Nancy’s stole my heart! I always order from here Via Grubhub and the food is delicious!!! I usually get the thin crust pizza with buffalo wings and it is incredible ! I’ve been ordering from here bi-weekly, and the food has been consistently good! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
Submitted by Ann K on 06/26/2022
Kenny Burning 5 stars rating.
I am definitely from out of town, I'm on vacation from Canada and ordered this tonight.
Phenomenal! I will be eating this for lunch and supper the next couple days ????
Super fresh, well made and delicious.
Submitted by Kenny Burning on 06/25/2022
Damien Jones 5 stars rating.
Best deep dish (aka "stuffed") pizza I've found since moving to Chicago. Their thin crust is really good too. Probably order the latter more than the former.
Submitted by Damien Jones on 06/14/2022
Valerie K. 5 stars rating.
We got pizza door dashed to us, but the deep dish was delicious, cannoli was good and the Caesar salad was interesting. The Caesar dressing was good but bacon bits is an interesting choice.
Loved it!
Submitted by Valerie K. on 05/24/2022
Matt F 3 stars rating.
Great pizza.. but incorrect info on Google. Despite the green check next to “Dine In”, and all the TVs being on around the bar inside - they are not open for dine in. Wish I had known this prior to walking over with my parents from out of town. Hopefully they update it soon, and this helps others not be misled. Delivery for now!
Submitted by Matt F on 05/22/2022
Ian Tracy 5 stars rating.
The deep dish at Nancy's is hands down the best pizza in Chicago. I had it twice to confirm, and am floored at how good this is. Great work, Nancy!
My ingredients were: Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, mushroom, onion, and pineapple
Submitted by Ian Tracy on 03/30/2022
Lina Lee 5 stars rating.
I last ordered from Nancy’s once before over a year ago and just ordered for the second time. Excellent thin crust, and I appreciate that’s the case for a small, sometimes a small pizza isn’t done as well as the larger sizes. Ordered bone in wings and they’re quality, not breaded or maybe dusted with flour which is how I like them. Onions also very good. I’ll be ordering from here when I have a thin crust fix and don’t want to receive a soggy pie.
Submitted by Lina Lee on 02/22/2022
Melissa Raney 5 stars rating.
The BEST! I tried the "original" deep dish a while back and it was great. Then National Pizza Day 50% off twisted my arm to try the thin crust. It was the best, I've had in a while. Besides the discount, which made it what a pizza used to cost (before all the current fees and nonsense) the pizza, was perfectly cooked- toppings, cheese all came together for a great pizza! This will be my new go-to place from now on!
Submitted by Melissa Raney on 02/10/2022
Lindsey Roddy 5 stars rating.
Tastey thin crust pizza, love their sauce. My husband got what he wanted on his half, and I got what I wanted on mine and we shared a medium for dinner.
Submitted by Lindsey Roddy on 09/26/2021
Ben Cordes 5 stars rating.
Delicious deep dish pizza and warm, friendly staff. Quality ingredients all the way around. Dough, cheese, toppings, and especially the sauce all burst with flavor. Highly recommended!
Submitted by Ben Cordes on 09/13/2021
Jasmine Davis 5 stars rating.
Pizza is one of my food staples,next to fruits and vegetables. I usually only review restaurants if I’d rate them a 4 or 5, so I haven’t reviewed quite a few pizza places here in Chicago. When I opened this pizza I knew it was a five. It was easily one of the best thin crust pizzas I’ve had, especially in Chicago. I didn’t know Nancy’s invented the “Chicago (stuffed) style pizza”, though you’d think they had something to do with perfecting thin crust pizzas as well. It was that good.
Submitted by Jasmine Davis on 09/06/2021
Kalamity Deschain 4 stars rating.
Ordered a medium thin crust pepperoni pizza -- loved the crackery crust and seriously carmelized cheese. Tried the mozz sticks -- which were stretchy and yummy, but just a bit bland. The pesto ailoi and the boom boom sauce are just freaking awesome. The breadsticks are God's gift to Chicago. Crispy crusty crunchy outside and fluffy inside.
Submitted by Kalamity Deschain on 04/19/2021
