Pizza Boy Chicago Reviews
Submitted by Derek D on 02/13/2022
Derek D 1 stars rating.
First time trying this place, ordered on line half cheese and half pepperoni and this is what I got!
Tried calling the number listed on Google and their website and of course it not working.
So here you can read about the quality of your pizza and service, SMH!
DvD DvD 5 stars rating.
Met the Pizza Boy & Pizza Boy's wife, great people! The food was great, I received my order wrong but the wrong order was still good. The pizza was finger licking good, thank you!
Submitted by Dvd Dvd on 09/09/2022
Ashley Pantaleo 5 stars rating.
I take my 12 year old son here at least once a week. My personal favorite slices are the New York style ???? My son loves the classic cheese and always has 2 slices. The pizza is super delicious and earned its spot as our favorite pizza place.
Submitted by Ashley Pantaleo on 09/01/2022
Big guy 5 stars rating.
First time visiting. The Detroit style pizza was great . And the owner gave my daughter her deep dish for free. She said it was the best pizza she ever had. The customer service was the best. Can't wait to return.
Submitted by Big Guy on 08/21/2022
Erin Kane 3 stars rating.
Bummed as we want to LOVE this place as we live in the area but have tried ordering multiple times. First off, garlic knots should include a side marinara, too greasy and dry without. Second of all, the pizzas are good but overpriced and smaller than advertised. There’s better pizza for better cost in the area unfortunately.
Submitted by Erin Kane on 07/23/2022
Ella Torres 5 stars rating.
Delicious Chicago Pizza!! If you are in Chicago you have to try out this pizzeria! Great atmosphere and ambiance and the owner Carlo is super gracious, warm, and kind!
-The Fernandez/Torres Family
Glendale, AZ
Submitted by Ella Torres on 07/20/2022
Ariana Nikitas 5 stars rating.
We went in for a few slices to take home. When we got home, one of the slices was not what we ordered. I called just to let them know, and the manager delivered the slice I did order quickly--and it was hot. And the pizza was great.
Submitted by Ariana Nikitas on 07/01/2022
Holly Mizak 5 stars rating.
Best pizza around! Finally a found it. It has the best Chicago tavern style thin crust pizza. I haven’t tried the other kind yet maybe one day I will.
Submitted by Holly Mizak on 05/28/2022
Gino Fiore 5 stars rating.
Amazing place. The pizza, atmosphere and owners are awesome. Carlo is a family man and works his butt off everyday with his staff. We always order 'The Don' detroit style pizza, it's stupid good. 12/10 for Pizzaboy.
Submitted by Gino Fiore on 05/04/2022
SMASH Toys and Collectibles 5 stars rating.
The perfect thin cheese slice in Edison Park! Perfect ratio of cheese to sauce to dough. Like a New York slice but it's not greasy on the bottom still crispy. We'll be back!
Submitted by Smash Toys And Collectibles on 05/03/2022
Mark D 5 stars rating.
Great place, had the thin crust pizza it was fantastic, the people I were with had a order of fried mushrooms which they enjoyed very much. The gelato and tiramisu were delicious as well. Will definitely be back, shout out to Carlo and his employees!
Submitted by Mark D on 04/24/2022
Cristina Diaz 5 stars rating.
I initially went because his wife came out in a show I watched and I honestly wasn't disappointed. The thin crust was crispy and delicious. The appetizers I ordered were bomb, especially the wings. I can't wait to go back.
Submitted by Cristina Diaz on 04/19/2022
Julian Perez (ItsJuuuuliansWRD) 5 stars rating.
Easily the best experience I’ve ever had at a restaurant. And Pizza boy exceeded my expectations. We were treated with such hospitality and friendliness. The Detroit style pizza was unlike any pizza I’ve ever had in Chicago crunchy crispy crust and edges and airy fluffy on the inside. On top drizzled with hot honey. And loved the quality of the meats the pepperoni was superb along with the sausage.
The chicken wings are amongst the best I’ve had as well perfect amount of meat and sauced perfectly. Curly fries were crispy and delicious. And the owner of the restaurant was so kind for us to try a thin crust pizza slice and fried dough with chocolate and caramel drizzled.
Submitted by Julian Perez (itsjuuuulianswrd) on 01/13/2022
Chris Villareale 5 stars rating.
Yoooo! We were visiting from across the country. I'll be honest, I didn't know what to expect. Of course, like tons of other people, I heard about your place from the Smothered show on TLC. Your mother-in-law reminds me a lot of my mother. Had high hopes but you guys blew me out of the water! Amazing pie. Perfect test for any pizzeria is a standard cheese pizza. This passed with flying colors (red, white, green). Sauce was seasoned perfectly. Perfect amount of cheese. Made me feel like I was eating something from the old country. Even packaged for take out like what I grew up with. Carlo, you guys are doing it up nice. Keep up the good work.
Submitted by Chris Villareale on 10/25/2021
Sodgerel Tserendorj 5 stars rating.
This is our second time eating here. We loved The first time; that is why we came back.
We had the Edison Park special; it was DELICIOUS. I don't know how they get that perfect crust. The crust is perfectly flaky and not soggy at all. The toppings are very fresh.
In addition to that, the owner is super nice and a hard working, family man. The staff is nice. The waitress was very attentive; excellent service. I liked it.
Now this is our the favorite pizza place and we don't mind the time we spend to drive here and wait to eat. It is all worth it.
Submitted by Sodgerel Tserendorj on 09/01/2021
olivia C 5 stars rating.
My mom and I are huge fans of the show Smothered so when we found out this restaurant was only a half hour away we practically jumped right in the car!! It definitely didn’t disappoint, the pizza is made from scratch and the ingredients are fantastic quality and fresh, and the crust is phenomenally flaky and buttery if you get the double dough thin crust! The mozzarella sticks and garlic knots were to DIE for!! We couldn’t help but ask to get a picture with Carlo and he was super nice! We totally expected him to be annoyed but he seemed genuinely interested in meeting us and was a great conversationalist, he even autographed my pizza box! We are totally going to come back here. Thank you Carlo and the rest of the Pizzaboy staff for making this experience so wonderful!
Submitted by Olivia C on 08/11/2021
Michele Richards 5 stars rating.
A+++ experience! An absolute must have! Everything about this place was amazing! The staff is so friendly, the restaurant is so clean and welcoming and the food is outstanding! The owner even came around to make sure his customers were satisfied. Please, wether you live in the area or are just traveling through you MUST put this on your list of places to eat! You will NOT be disappointed! (And don’t forget to finish off your meal with the fried dough! YUM!! )
Submitted by Michele Richards on 07/28/2021
L L 5 stars rating.
One word to describe pizza boy AMAZING! The pizza was the best I ever had! Not even joking! The sauce was so good! The owner sent us some fried dough omg was the best fried dough I ever had! Thank you for being so awesome! One more thing the staff was also amazing! I just love this place!
Submitted by L L on 07/21/2021
John Pozo 5 stars rating.
Yep! Great Pizza can be found here. The garlic knots were a great appetizer to hold us over until the pizza. The smothered was amazing, the cheese thin crust was good as well.
Carlo and Kathy were great and super friendly. The stuff was quick and friendly too.
The desert was equally as great the cannoli and gelto were a good choice.
Overall enjoyed the experience and definitely will be coming back!
Submitted by John Pozo on 07/16/2021
Tom Z 4 stars rating.
Excellent Food
I went for lunch and had a slice of the Da Pizzaboy. It is topped with Italian Beef and Hot Giardiniera. I loved it. The crust was crunchy, the sauce was excellent and the toppings were great.
The people working there were amazing. More than once someone checked on how I was doing. There are quite a few tables inside.
I will be returning to try some other items.
Bicycling: Northwest Highway is pretty easy going. A little further south there is a dedicated bicycle lane. There are multiple places to lock your bike. There was also an outdoor dining area.
Submitted by Tom Z on 07/01/2021
