Tonys Pizza Reviews
Submitted by Teren Russell on 05/28/2022
Teren Russell 5 stars rating.
Today was my first time eating Tony's Pizza. A friend introduced me to the establishment. It is by far the BEST Pizza I have ever had. Whenever your on Knickerbocker Avenue, stop in and get yourself a slice or two.
Joe Ahearn 5 stars rating.
Love this pizzeria's vibe. Always get a tasty new slice every time I come through, and the boys at the counter are always super friendly.
Submitted by Joe Ahearn on 06/12/2022
Ruthie Elizabeth 4 stars rating.
good pizza and quirky staff. all in all, it was good ‘za and i would defo go back.
Submitted by Ruthie Elizabeth on 05/10/2022
James McNally 5 stars rating.
I eat Tony's pizza 2-5 times a week. These guys hold it down big time. The pizza is good, you have a lot of choices. They are legit to deal with too, you know it gets hectic in there and they keep things running professional. I love Tony's.
Submitted by James Mcnally on 05/09/2022
Don T 1 stars rating.
I’m not sure why but the service here is pretty inconsistent. Some days it’s good others it’s awful. I called recently to place an order for delivery and the person taking my order over the phone was extremely rude and nasty. I’m guessing a question like what is my total? Is too much to ask when purchasing food. I’ll definitely never spend my money here again! The pizza here is decent but there’s decent pizza all over the city.
Submitted by Don T on 04/30/2022
Wendy Rodriguez-Figueroa 5 stars rating.
We ordered cheese pies for my daughter’s birthday at Area 53. Pizza was excellent, arrived perfect to eat and the delivery man was courteous and professional. Thank you for every single delicious slice.
Submitted by Wendy Rodriguez-figueroa on 03/06/2022
G 5 stars rating.
Great place. Staff is kind and helpful. Theirs is something for everyone there.
Vegan options as well as gluten free options are available.
They have a large array of items to chose from(ice cream, cake, pastries, burgers, vegan burgers, etc.).
Their plain pizza is good. Has seating.
Delivery is available.
Submitted by G on 11/28/2021
Maia Pujara 5 stars rating.
I haven’t seen any reviews of their gluten free pizza so thought I would share the amazing experience I had with ordering a gluten free pizza at Tony’s. I ordered the chicken bacon ranch pizza on gluten free crust, and immediately they knew to make it a special order to add grilled instead of breaded chicken, which not every restaurant knows to do. When I opened the box, I was pleasantly surprised at how large the order was (most gluten free pizzas are small personal sized pizzas) and what a work of art it was. Not to mention it was incredibly delicious. Highly recommend!
Submitted by Maia Pujara on 06/27/2021
Gisselle Sanchez 5 stars rating.
Good I love this place they have clean sanitary conditions,the Sicilians are the best. They have a bathroom , provide us with toppings as well , they have added about 2 cases of cakes/pastries. One case of gelato ice cream ???? , which looks good ????.
Submitted by Gisselle Sanchez on 08/21/2019
Sarah Sos 5 stars rating.
Came here for our first meal off the plane and man were we treated well. The customer service was great and the pizza was delicious - perfect thickness to the crust. I got the vegan buffalo chicken and it was to die for. They said they make almost every version of pizza vegan - so good!
Submitted by Sarah Sos on 04/17/2019
