Garden City Pizza and Catering Reviews
Submitted by Jennifer Chen on 03/14/2022
Jennifer Chen 5 stars rating.
My office always orders off the catering menu atleast once or twice a month. The penne alla vodka, mesculine salad & chicken parm is ALWAYS on point & never disappoints. So yummy!
Jupiter 5 stars rating.
My Food was amazing. The pizza was delicious and so were the wings.
Submitted by Jupiter on 07/21/2022
Mariana Torres (Salvi Nomad) 5 stars rating.
Excellent service! I order ahead and they are always on time. Their penne a la vodka and mesclun salad is one of my faves. Super friendly staff and fair prices.
Submitted by Mariana Torres (salvi Nomad) on 05/30/2022
Kris S 5 stars rating.
Had the spinach pinwheel. Freshest and softest pinwheel I’ve ever had! I always look for them at decent pizza spots, and thus place is by far the winner. Enjoyed my slice as well. Stewart’s root beer in the bottle and a nice booth to enjoy lunch with a buddy while we caught up. Big parking lot out back too.
Submitted by Kris S on 04/21/2022
Peter Es 5 stars rating.
Good pizza and fast service. I like the classic slice. It is better than most places.
Submitted by Peter Es on 03/24/2022
Ben D 1 stars rating.
Pile of grease cheese slice w burnt stuff under the crust that made the slice disgusting. Kitchen looks cramped and dirty. Can see why the new pizzeria across the street has more foot traffic - go there.
Submitted by Ben D on 01/03/2022
Thomas McNamee 3 stars rating.
I went there for lunch had a slice of chicken franchise pizza, it was a nice size. The chicken was a little dry along with the sauce.
I thought they were kind of pricey, $8,.50
For a slice of chicken franchise pizza
and a bottle of Snapple. I would give them a try again.
Submitted by Thomas Mcnamee on 10/22/2021
R M P 2 stars rating.
I bought two pies and couldn't enjoy it nor my family because bottom was black. I haven't had the best of luck with pizzeria spots. The last few was horrible from ingredients used to it being charred on bottom. The top was fine at this pizzeria but you cannot enjoy a pizza if bottom is black. The oven needs to be cleaned.
Submitted by R M P on 05/21/2021
Peter A 5 stars rating.
This is my go-to pizza spot for delivery to my office. After you order a couple times GCP will have your information on file (address and credit card) making reordering a breeze.
Submitted by Peter A on 01/11/2021
Travis 5 stars rating.
The food is always really good and the service is nice. My mom’s in love with the mesclun salad, but my favs are their speciality slices.
Submitted by Travis on 12/28/2018
