Black Tap Reviews
Submitted by Nicole F on 05/20/2022
Nicole F 5 stars rating.
Great intriguing food and great service. The crazy shakes are so much fun. Felt like a kid and the music had us dancing in our seats. ????????????????????
Chantal Theresa 5 stars rating.
On another level of good. Be sure to get the crazy shakes and their burgers!
Submitted by Chantal Theresa on 07/20/2022
One90_ Official 4 stars rating.
Liked the food. The person at the front did however make us wait 45min for a table that was empty the whole time. And sat other walk ins until we had to ask again for a table. Warm water to drink and unsweetened tea. But I'd still give an overall satisfactory experience.
Submitted by One90_ Official on 07/16/2022
Johna Wright 5 stars rating.
i came here on a mission to try one of the famous freakshakes, and i accomplished just that! these aren’t cheap (obviously) and they’re really sweet, but the point is to be over the top and fun. i felt like a big kid but it tasted amazing :) i would highly recommend you to come here if you’re looking for a similar lighthearted experience. if you’re not into the milkshakes though, they also have fabulous burgers!
Submitted by Johna Wright on 07/15/2022
Leann Forst, MBA, CHC, CEOC 2 stars rating.
No one answers the phone to make a reservation but then when we showed up several available tables were ‘reserved’. Waited 45 minutes even though no one was in front of us. My milkshake was dripping and sopping like it sat in the kitchen for awhile before they brought it out. It wasn’t very cold.
Submitted by Leann Forst, Mba, Chc, Ceoc on 06/20/2022
myriah_smile 5 stars rating.
The staff is awesome and so nice. I made and reservation for 2 and got stood up so I was a little upset. But the staff were really uplifting they have great energy that made me feel welcomed, even tho I was just stood up on a date lmao
Submitted by Myriah_smile on 06/15/2022
Gabriella 2 stars rating.
The wait is not worth the food at all. I was quite excited about their extravagant milkshakes, but they did not live up to my expectations whatsoever. We ordered three different ones and all of the milkshake bases were flavorless. The cake on top of mine was also flavorless. The service is slow and the ambiance is horrible. The only decent thing was the burger, but you can get something just as good at any other burger place.
Submitted by Gabriella on 05/19/2022
Analie C (AnalieNYC) 4 stars rating.
First time at this Black Tap Burger place. We were warned before being seated that the milkshake machine was down. Kind of odd since they're known for their supreme shakes.
DRINKS: We were going to split a milkshake but couldn't so we each got charged lemonades, which means they had vodka. They were tasty and easy to drink.
FOOD: For apps, we got fried mozzarella cheese and crispy brussel sprouts. Both were so yummy. The sauce for the mozzarella cheese was delish. The mulberry street burger was goood as were the wings. The sauce on the wings was on the side. After we finished, we were told the milkshake machine was working again so we got the cookies and cream supreme milkshake. It was great looking and tasted amazing.
SERVER/SERVICE: Our server Anthony was great. Was helpful about food choice and kept tabs on us , making sure we were okay.
VIBE: It's a casual, chill spot. There's a bar area in the front. They have outdoor dining available as well.
Submitted by Analie C (analienyc) on 05/13/2022
TJG 5 stars rating.
Delicious burgers and fries. Crazy shakes. Small, intimate setting that can get loud when busy. Was busy during much of the open hours. Full bar with great draft selection. Friendly staff.
Submitted by Tjg on 04/24/2022
Amad Shk 5 stars rating.
Had a longer wait than advised but the manager — a nice young lady whose name I can’t recall, and the waitress Amber were fantastic and made up for the delay. Food was also amazing. The receptionists do need some training as they were a bit crude.
Submitted by Amad Shk on 03/14/2022
