Gramercy Tavern Reviews
Submitted by Howard T on 09/04/2022
Howard T 5 stars rating.
Back for the first time in a long time. Still great ingredients, execution, and flavors. It may not be as inventive as other places, but the quality is still up there. Every dish was well prepared, and the service was great.
Allan Clements 5 stars rating.
Had dinner at the Tavern. We both had the Tavern Burger, probably the best burger I have ever had. Highly recommend. Also got the Blueberry pie and the Beignets for dessert. Both were exceptional, but I think the beignets were better.
Submitted by Allan Clements on 09/14/2022
Lisa McDermott 3 stars rating.
Nice breakfast, plated beautifully, tasted good not great. Also ordered fish tacos and crab Benedict. Crab was by far the best of the three. Overall good meal but pricey
Submitted by Lisa Mcdermott on 09/12/2022
Mannavy You 5 stars rating.
Came here during my trip to NYC with my bf, we looked up top restaurants in the city and were lucky to snatch a table d'hôte reservation for the same night. First of all, we made the mistake of eating an entire hummus plate plus a few drinks at a comedy show right before and we were feeling pretty full. We still had to get the 5 course meal as per our reservation and we still managed to finish everything! We were so full yet could not stop eating. Needless to say it was absolutely amazing from the creative dishes to the decor to our super lovely waitress. It was one of the highlights of our trip!
Submitted by Mannavy You on 08/26/2022
Thanya Jai 5 stars rating.
Gramercy Tavern is perfect. Unbelievably excellent service and food! Plus, it is a Hospitality Included restaurant. The servers are super friendly and attentive. The tasting menu is the best. The desserts are simply sublime. We tried 3 , 2 and 1 Michelin star restaurants on this NYC in 2 years. Gramercy Tavern takes the crown hands down! Its the best even compared to other Michelin 1 or 2 stars in the world that we have tried. We are in love with this restaurant! Fully deserved it’s Michelin star rating ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️
Submitted by Thanya Jai on 08/26/2022
Navah Fuchs 5 stars rating.
This was a truly special meal and the staff were attentive and mindful of our conversation cadence.
I started off with a C and T cocktail which was A+ for a gin lover. It also wasn't too strong or overpowering to get in the way of the wine pairing.
The entire tasting menus was really special but the absolute standout was the duck. Best duck I've ever had and a strong finisher protein. The dessert was refreshing and left me feeling satisfied without sugar overload.
I'd plan to come hungry and indulge in the tasting menu + wine pairing. While they have a la carte, the composition of the meal was so perfectly balanced you'd be doing yourself a disservice not to go for it.
100% recommend ❤
Submitted by Navah Fuchs on 08/25/2022
Hye Young Chyun 5 stars rating.
Hands down best burger and food with the friendly staff catering to needs meticulously by being steps ahead (considerate and friendly) at a beautiful grand lively atmosphere where you can go and indulge comfortably being a foodie. (Beer & Burger & Jerk chicken i forgot to take pictures as the food was phenomenal, the quality of the food and service is top notch!)
Submitted by Hye Young Chyun on 08/21/2022
Michel Schoemaker 5 stars rating.
Amazing food and service. The burger, beef tartare and chocolate pudding were the standouts. Ambiance was good, though the tavern was a bit more elegant than I expected.
Submitted by Michel Schoemaker on 08/21/2022
Eloise J. Li 3 stars rating.
The service was great, but the food did not live up to the hype in my opinion. The ambiance was great though. I didn't really enjoy my entree, the eggplant. It was sour and the very chewy, hard pieces of skin mixed made me not want to continue eating it. I tried liking it, but I had to get my husband to finish the rest. I had a similar dish recently at a different restaurant which didn't have a Michelin star and it was so much better. I enjoyed the ramp flatbread. The beef tartare was very flavourful. My husband said he enjoyed the duck fat chips the most though. The passion fruit souffle was okay.
Submitted by Eloise J. Li on 08/17/2022
Tobias Weimann 5 stars rating.
An incredible dining experience! The burger was to die for. Didn’t need any sauce with it as the meat and cheese was so flavorful. The wine and desert (blueberry pie) was great too. Will definitely come again, thanks again for the great experience!
Submitted by Tobias Weimann on 08/08/2022
April-nyc 5 stars rating.
We had the 5 course seasonal tasting menu. Food was great and service was excellent.
The seating by the bar area was really loud but luckily we got a table all the way in the back which was much quieter and better for conversation.
Overall we had a great dinner.
Submitted by April-nyc on 02/25/2022
Katie Flegenheimer 4 stars rating.
Food was incredible and delicious. I loved everything we ordered! The burger is to die for.
The tavern is really loud though, you kind of need to scream across your table to have a conversation.
Submitted by Katie Flegenheimer on 02/22/2022
Gordon Mitchell 5 stars rating.
(12/19/2021) A LOVELY experience every time we visit. We have been visiting Gramercy Tavern for the past 20 years and they never disappoint. From grabbing a glass of wine at the bar or chowing down on Roasted Oysters and Beef Tartare, the ambience and the service is second to none! It's always a MUST VISIT when we fly in from Seattle, and we typically visit more than once during our time in town. We already can't wait to return !!
Submitted by Gordon Mitchell on 12/26/2021
Yolanda C. 5 stars rating.
Enjoyed a tasting menu this past Saturday. We were very much looking forward to it after reading reviews and a friend from NY recommended it. We were fortunate to get a reservation when it opened up for our weekend visit to NY. We enjoyed every moment of the experience. The food was delicious of course and the service was impeccable. The staff was very attentive and made some great recommendations. Mike was our main server but we had several other who attended to us. We really enjoy our time there and would definitely go back when we are in the city. Thank you Gramercy Tavern for a lovely evening. We needed it.
Submitted by Yolanda C. on 12/13/2021
Kathleen Medina 5 stars rating.
Burger was our favorite it’s just sooooo juicy! The dessert was a very close second. It was a caramelized cheesecake with mandarin sorbet and it was delicious. I didn’t get the cocktails but they were all delicious. We sat outside and it was such a beautiful night in a lovely neighborhood. Great date night place
Submitted by Kathleen Medina on 12/09/2021
cristina p 5 stars rating.
This tavern is the perfect spot to enjoy a drink with friends or to enjoy a delicious meal at the table.
Staff is very kind, polite, professional.
The kitchen worked to meet my need of lactose free meals, and somehow prepared a salad that was simply, the best salad ever.
Pasta was al dente, very tasty.
Absolutely recommended.
Submitted by Cristina P on 12/09/2021
Rob 5 stars rating.
We ordered the pre fix tasting menu in the Dining Room. We opted not for the pairing because that would have been too much alcohol. Not cheap. Good flavor on all food. Funny that my favorite was the bread. Don't be afraid to ask for more.
Submitted by Rob on 09/16/2021
Mac Adelman 5 stars rating.
Gramercy Tavern checks off every box for me. The service, drinks, and food were all very solid. I have no complaints at all, to be honest. From drinks to food items, our waitress was knowledgeable about each menu item. If I had to recommend anything from the menu it would certainly be the oysters and the steak. The cheesecake that I had was good, but it didn’t stand out like the rest of the meal did.
Submitted by Mac Adelman on 09/10/2021
Teddy Bourgeois 5 stars rating.
Delicious! We sat in the dining room for the tasting menu ($148/pp). The meal was well balanced and flavorful. While everything was delicious, the dessert course was perhaps my unexpected favorite. Great for a special date night or business dinner
Submitted by Teddy Bourgeois on 09/04/2021
Elizabeth Yee 5 stars rating.
Service was phenomenal, but I don't expect anything less at Gramercy. I have heard about their excellence of food and service.
Went with a group of 5 and was able to try most of the appetizers and desserts. The entree was delightful, didn't know a carrot could be so sweet. Skirt steak was very tender and cooked well. Duck pasta was a surprise and a lot lighter then you would think.
Great place to go for groups or date night.
Submitted by Elizabeth Yee on 08/30/2021
