Olio e Piu Reviews
Submitted by Nada Elassadi on 12/30/2021
Nada Elassadi 3 stars rating.
Honestly I'm only giving the 3 stars mainly for the ambiance of the place nothing more. It was my first time trying and I got the roasted beet salad and the fettuccine truffle pasta. It's way way more expensive than it really should. I know truffle is expensive but this dish was too small not even enough for one person and it was 50 dollars. I definitely left hungry :)
Believe me when I tell you the picture makes the dish look bigger than what it is. I've definitely tasted better truffle pasta before. The pasta itself was cooked to perfection though I'll give them that. The beet salad was honestly boring and didn'thave enough apples or blueberries, I asked the waiter if they can just toss some arugula in there before they bring it out and he said no we don't make changes.
I mostly give places more than one try before I decide to rate but I'm definitely not going back to this one. Their pizzas looked good as they were bringing them out to other tables- maybe try your luck there.
Ana O. 5 stars rating.
Food was delicious!! The restaurant decoration is Italian elegant casual, clean, great environment. Loved it!!! And the service was superb thanks to our waiter Gabriel that gave us an excellent hospitality, not easily find in NYC… overall an amazing experience!!!
Submitted by Ana O. on 07/25/2022
Demetrios Mina (Jimmy Mina) 5 stars rating.
When I was in Manhattan I Went and had lunch with my friends in the Village in NY City. It was Wonderful to sit outside and talk and eat with my friends and view the city at the same time. Absolutely amazing! Love Eating outside in Ny! So beautiful. The restaurant was really good the service was great, definitely going back! Love walking around and trying different restaurants and see different places in the Village. I will see you again soon!!
Submitted by Demetrios Mina (jimmy Mina) on 07/11/2022
Grace Ryu 5 stars rating.
Perfect place for brunch. Indoor was so adorable and outdoor looked like a great option too. The food was great. I might have had very high expectation for the carbonara but it still hit the spot and the pizza was delicious. I would love to try other dishes some other time. If you are looking for a place for a date or brunch, I would totally come here
Submitted by Grace Ryu on 06/20/2022
Bianca Cheek 5 stars rating.
Amazing Italian food and great service. Susana was our waitress and she was awesome! I highly recommend this restaurant if you’re around the area. All of the employees are so nice and attentive. They really want to make sure you’re having a great time. Definitely will come back next time!
Submitted by Bianca Cheek on 06/19/2022
Ms. Tran 3 stars rating.
This restaurant is more about the scene than being remarkable in any way. It sits on a prominent location in West Village with lively outdoor seating areas covered with greenery. Service was nice, but a bit slow and we had to wave our server down if we needed…anything.
We intended on having a light lunch and drinks, but the salad choices were limited and the salad we did order was $21 although it would have cost no more than $3 to make. Pizza was good; thin, Neapolitan style, chewy crust.
Submitted by Ms. Tran on 06/12/2022
Srida Saraogi 5 stars rating.
I’m usually not a fan of Italian food, because I always feel it is over priced for average pasta. However, I did find the food here worth it! The spaghetti carbonara was my favorite. I didn’t love the pistachio chocolate dessert. The pizza was good too! I would definitely go back and do recommend this place. Definitely on the pricey side.
Submitted by Srida Saraogi on 06/10/2022
Air Z 5 stars rating.
What a nice outdoor seating, so lovely and beautiful. I think my mom will be happy to come here to celebrate Mother's Day. Lovely cocktails, loved my seafood ink pasta and calamari, can't wait to come back to try their pizza next time.
Submitted by Air Z on 05/04/2022
Madhumitha Ramesh 4 stars rating.
Food was really good. Went on a weekend and ended up waiting for a good 20 mins. Their cocktails was sweet for me, their pasta and pizza both was amazing. It was very fresh, so it takes time for the food to come out. I felt this place was congested, but it’s everywhere in NYC. Better heating is required for outdoor seats. Overall, enjoyed my meal and would recommend.
Submitted by Madhumitha Ramesh on 04/20/2022
Tiberiu Hrihorciuc 4 stars rating.
Great restaurant. Truffle pasta was delicious and very creamy with a nice after taste.
The classic carbonara is also great.
Hen of the woods are steamed and without flavor.
Bathroom has a smell but manager seemed very accommodating and tried to help.
After they learn to not pick up the plates while people are still eating they can become a 5 star establishment for sure :)
Submitted by Tiberiu Hrihorciuc on 01/06/2022
