Sarabeths Reviews
Submitted by Sarah Philpott on 06/25/2022
Sarah Philpott 4 stars rating.
Very busy and a bit loud, but the service was prompt and the food was excellent. Went on a weekday morning and were seated immediately, but I imagine reservations being the best option on a weekend. We tried the wild mushroom scramble with popover and lemon ricotta pancakes. Delicious!
K Haverty 3 stars rating.
This place was absolutely packed at 9:30 on the Saturday morning but we only had to wait about five minutes to be seated. We started with a basket of Popovers and they were not good at all. They were tough and tasteless, but they did come with some delicious jam… Both berry and apricot. The spinach and goat cheese omelette was not like a traditional omelette where the spinach is on the inside, it was all cooked together with a smear of goat cheese on the inside. It wasn’t bad but it definitely wasn’t fabulous. It also came with thin sourdough toast that was both dry and chewy and practically inedible. The Goldilocks scramble pop over was also a disappointment. it had very little locks and was just another pop over on the side. The salmon eggs Benedict was the best choice on the menu, and tasted great. If you think that ordering the apricot sausage is going to get you something new and interesting, that is not the case, you will get some very good sausage piled on top of a puddle of apricot jam. We also ordered a couple of cappuccinos that were tiny but good and an orange juice that was great. Our total came to about $140 before tip and I would not recommend this restaurant. The prices are high end, but the food is not.
Submitted by K Haverty on 08/27/2022
Siamak Sanati 3 stars rating.
Service is very good, strong management team as I understand it. Coffee was of good quality so was the food. French toasts were think and soggy in the middle, however my omelette was well prepared. Very noisy, you can hardly hear anything. Pricy for what they serve, perhaps taking advantage their location. I won’t recommend it tho. Jams restaurant nearby is a better value!!
Submitted by Siamak Sanati on 08/13/2022
Sil Medrano 5 stars rating.
Absolutely incredible, everything was delicious and so well-balanced. The service was exceptional, the mimosas were amazing, the ambiance is perfect for every reunion with a date, friends or family. Best meal I've had, and that includes some Run here, you will not be disappointed.
Submitted by Sil Medrano on 05/17/2022
Marco Taroni 4 stars rating.
I had an amazing breakfast here, during the Five Boro Bike Tour.
The position is very nice, in front of central park and there are some table also outside.
There’s several nice dishes, but for my opinion a must are the pancakes…probably the best pancakes I have ever eat!!
To be honest, the prices are high but for the view and the quality of the food, i highly suggest to come here!!
Submitted by Marco Taroni on 05/07/2022
jason hall 5 stars rating.
Had easter brunch there, excellent service, great views and killer food. We got the muffin and preserves platter to start the preserves were out of this world. Then I got the salmon benedict and truffle fries which were so good, my wife got the cream cheese scallion popover which was also excellent. Great place will definitely be back!
Submitted by Jason Hall on 04/17/2022
Richard 3 stars rating.
Fancy place and of course wicked expensive. It was busy when we came around noon so we had to wait 30 minutes for a table. I ordered the $25 apple cinnamon french toast which came with a really good apple jam. The waiter offered bacon (4 slices) and I wouldn’t have said yes if i knew it was $14 but I enjoyed my meal. My friend had a very different experience. He ordered a $15 fruit bowl which came with watermelon, strawberries, grapefruit and oranges (none of these were sweet), and a $15 cinnamon bun that was clearly old and tasted terrible. My Pillsbury at home is way better. Sent it back and they were nice enough to remove it from the bill. Our seat was by the door so it was pretty cold with people constantly coming in and out. The waterboy was incredibly rude when i asked him where the bathroom was like it was a dumb question but this was my first time here so excuse me. If my food wasn’t so good I would’ve given them a 1/5 just for the mediocre experience. Definitely not worth the money.
Submitted by Richard on 04/15/2022
Fernando Graham 5 stars rating.
Wow, it was better than I expected it would to be. The tomato soup was the best I have ever had, and the french toast was great. The benedicts were okay, but compared to the others, they were sub par. Also, their coffee is great too! Highly recommend!
Submitted by Fernando Graham on 03/06/2022
Lorizbeth 5 stars rating.
The service was outstanding. The food was so delicious. Everything was fresh, flavorful and fantastic. Their popovers are so good ! Crispy on the outside and airy on the inside. I recommend buying their marmalade by the jar. You won’t regret it.
Submitted by Lorizbeth on 02/06/2022
Reid Lyness 4 stars rating.
The salmon eggs Benedict was delicious. Bacon was too perfection. The lemon ricotta pancakes were pretty good, was expecting more ricotta but all in all delicious breakfast spot to go to. Wait service is nice and efficient!
Submitted by Reid Lyness on 01/15/2022
