Mitchells Soul Food Reviews
Submitted by Vaughn Dabney on 03/06/2017
Vaughn Dabney 3 stars rating.
It Greens were good, fried catfish was great, and the mac and cheese was ok. Portions were good in size. Yams weren't that great. It was almost like a glaze of cinnamon on them similar to Cinnabons. They weren't very good. Yams should be simple. Overall I ate most of the food.
Ian Manuel 5 stars rating.
Mitchell's is the best Soul Food Spot in Brooklyn. It really reminds be of that deep diwn South home cooking!
Submitted by Ian Manuel on 07/14/2022
Kaia Zawadi 2 stars rating.
This place fell off hard! They are not as good as they were in the 90's and 00s and mostly everything was just meh and boring. I know what good soul food is and this isn't it. The mac and cheese was mad nasty and lacked flavor, no soul at all. My husband had the fried chicken and he said it tasted old and dry and made his stomach upset. I had the turkey wings which tasted ok. The portions were really small. The banana pudding was good though. I won't be back, just go to 95 south or sugar hill, their food is tastier.
Submitted by Kaia Zawadi on 06/29/2022
Joel Mcleod 5 stars rating.
My spot for soul food..Love the fried chicken and smothered turkey wings. Also the potato salad ????. Price is very reasonable!!
Submitted by Joel Mcleod on 06/19/2022
Tracy Staten 2 stars rating.
The food has no taste. Needs seasoning. The gentleman who served us was very pleasant and attentive.
Submitted by Tracy Staten on 06/10/2022
Angie Spann 3 stars rating.
Food was just okay. Mac n cheese was mushy and lacked flavor, yams were just okay, fried chicken was fine. No frills hole in the wall, reccomend take out, not dine in.
Submitted by Angie Spann on 04/27/2022
silent tripper 4 stars rating.
Good humble food. If u r starving, they serve a healthy size of meal. Service is straightforward and unpretentious. If u r lucky enough like me, u could have a free pound cake and hear the madame of the cafe belt out some good vocals together with the tunes on the radio! I gave 4 stars cos it is cash only! #buyblack
Submitted by Silent Tripper on 12/30/2021
MOTIONRIVER 4 stars rating.
Cornbread was Awesome! Had the Cat Fish dinner. That was really good. This place is worth trying if your ever in the City????
Submitted by Motionriver on 09/14/2021
Tash P 3 stars rating.
This is definitely a no-thrills cash only spot where someone grandma is cooking in the kitchen...literally. She yelled at me once because I changed my order due to the fact I didn’t want to wait 20 minutes for them to make my wings. So there’s...that.
I ordered the fried fish with Mac n’ cheese and yams. The yams were really good. I didn’t like the Mac n cheese too much. The fish was crispy. The food is okay and the prices are pretty good. It ran be about $9.50.
I would give it a solid 3/5 overall.
Submitted by Tash P on 01/23/2021
Avinash Salgam (Avi) 5 stars rating.
The dinner menu may look a little pricey for a small restaurant such as this but it is totally worth the value and easily can be shared. The classic fried chicken with white meat was moist and had just enough flavor. The okra and corn was cooked very well and I wished I had ordered two as my sides but alas I didn't go wrong by ordering the cornbread (sweet). The venue has seating in the front and in the back with a small tour of the kitchen as u walk through.
Submitted by Avinash Salgam (avi) on 02/16/2018
