Petes Famous Pizza Reviews
Submitted by A Medina on 07/22/2022
A Medina 5 stars rating.
I didn’t catch the names of the two guys who were absolutely amazing to my family and furry baby dog! They received us with a wonderful welcome and lots of water right away after we came in super hot and thirsty as we walked from the Rocky statue. We ordered Philly Cheesesteaks and Mega Fries- super delicious and large portions. Thank you for a wonderful dinner!
Julian Andrews 5 stars rating.
New to the neighborhood, I've visited Pete's several times in the past few months. The service and food are always great. Cheesesteaks are good, pizza hits the spot, and wings are always a hit.
This past time I got the honey sriracha wings and they are probably my new favorite flavor over previous gotos "sweat and tears" and garlic parmesan.
They've got a decent size dine-in area but seem to be much more of a take-out / delivery specialty.
Submitted by Julian Andrews on 07/14/2022
Sarfaraz Ahmed 5 stars rating.
Good pizza, we liked loaded tots as well. Veggie cheesesteak didn’t taste so good probably it didn’t have much seasoning. Staff was friendly and explained about food.
Submitted by Sarfaraz Ahmed on 06/28/2022
Fred Acheampong 5 stars rating.
Thin pizza with just the right amount of bubbles on the crust. Good ratio of sauce to cheese and even though the slices were on the smaller size, they were still filling. We also got the fried fish sandwich, chicken tenders, and chocolate chip cookie, all of which were very good! For big orders, I suggest calling in ahead so you don't have to wait at the restaurant. They've also got a good selection of beer to pair with your meal
Submitted by Fred Acheampong on 06/18/2022
Jamie Cartwright 3 stars rating.
I know Pete’s is famous for pizza, but I ordered a sandwich and Greek fries from there (since it was on the menu and I was nearby), and honestly, it was mediocre at best. I know, I know - it’s a Pizza place (why would I get anything else?), but I firmly believe restaurants shouldn’t offer a broad menu if some of it is going to be cruddy, and it seems like that’s what Pete’s has done. If they want to keep to Pizza I think that would be far better for the consumer.
To dive into the Greek fries specifically, I’ve had some excellent Greek fries, and if my top were a 5 (at the Athenian Room in Chicago), then these were a 2 at best - oil, spices, and feta, but far too dry and not very hot for my liking.
Submitted by Jamie Cartwright on 06/11/2022
Matthew Cowan 4 stars rating.
Great cheesesteak and friendly service. Would definitely recommend if you are looking for a quick and tasty lunch in between museums. Brie and balsamic cheesesteak is definitely worth a try. Would return for sure!
Submitted by Matthew Cowan on 02/19/2022
Mark Morrell 5 stars rating.
Pete’s Pizza is a must for anyone who loves pizza. On this trip four separate slices in three boroughs in NYC and then Pete’s. The best, right out of oven. Staff made experience even better, original building. Very cool.
Submitted by Mark Morrell on 11/21/2021
brendamiller photography 5 stars rating.
Fresh; hot, delicious! Prepared as ordered! Enough to share. Terrific delivery service too; right on time. Worth your investment… Every Time Excitement!
Yes! I did it again. Fabulous people to work with and even better when the pizza is delivered ahead of schedule. Thank you! 5-Star!
Submitted by Brendamiller Photography on 11/10/2021
K F 4 stars rating.
Great service & good business relationship with the Greek spot down the block. Came here to pick up a couple drinks, but it smells so good inside I'll definitely be back for some pizza.
Update: came back to try their pizza & ordered a small white with broccoli. Not sure if they don't have ricotta or don't make white pizza, but what I got was a no-red-sauce pizza with broccoli. Tasted good but not what I ordered. Tiramisu dessert was great! Inhaled it.
Submitted by K F on 09/29/2021
Kelly C 5 stars rating.
This was a really nice, cozy little pizza shop. Really like the vibe in here. Our waitress was really kind and friendly. The burgers were juicy, the fries were crispy, the pizza was cheesy and the salad was so fresh. The food was delicious here. Good size portions and not too pricey. Will definitely come back!
Submitted by Kelly C on 09/10/2021
