Pop Pie Co. University Heights Reviews
Submitted by Darryl Gordon on 11/30/2021
Darryl Gordon 5 stars rating.
Hands down, the best pies in San Diego. My favorites, in order, are the Aussie, Steak and Ale, Chicken, Veggie. But make sure you get some of the sweet pies too as they are just as amazing.
John L (DefaultUser) 5 stars rating.
Had the sausage roll and a coconut cream pie. I now have a new favorite place for coconut creme pie.
Pop pie will be a destination every time I visit San Diego.
I can't wait to come back and try some savory pies.
Submitted by John L (defaultuser) on 09/25/2022
Lin A. 3 stars rating.
Decided to come here since it was close to our hotel and we wanted something sweet. Let me tell you, they LOVE sugar.
We got their guava and cream cheese hand pie, my husband wanted to try key lime sliced pie and I wanted to try coconut cream sliced pie and also got a cookie. First off, the guy gave us 2 key lime sliced pies, it was super sweet and some what tart, also the crust was hard and thick. We didn't get to taste the coconut cream pie. The cookie was good. Lastly, the guava and cream cheese, it was way too sweet for us, my husband loves sweets but even for him it was a no. I even tried to dissect the hand pie to scraped off the guava jam and that didn't helped. Tried to give it to my family members and they didn't want it.
In the attached pictures, as you can see it is 2 key lime pie slices. No coconut cream pie ????
If you LOVE sugary treats then give them a try.
Submitted by Lin A. on 08/16/2022
Ana & Karl Lies 3 stars rating.
This is a cute/ trendy place. Nice vibe. We had several items, chicken pot pie, breakfast pie, sausage roll and rhubarb pie. Also had a mocha coffee.
Cute concept. Store was clean, service was good (restroom was very clean). Most items cost around $9, my coffee was $6.
Everything was good but I can't say it was great. Tasty but nothing spectacular. The mocha choice however was very good.
My taste buds may just like a bit more "zing" than I found here but nothing was bad. All in all I'd go back but I don't know that I'd go way out of my way.
Submitted by Ana & Karl Lies on 08/03/2022
Minion Anuta 5 stars rating.
Cute & cozy place, VERY tasty pies, and super amazing and friendly staff!
We tried chicken pie, steak pie and Mushroom pie, all 3 were amazing! ????????????????
Submitted by Minion Anuta on 06/11/2022
James McIntyre 5 stars rating.
Great place! Great food and incredibly nice and helpful staff. They have a pie for everyone. We tried the chicken pot pie and the steak n ale one's and both were great. Definitely recommend in checking this place out!
Submitted by James Mcintyre on 06/08/2022
Steve H 4 stars rating.
Consider Pop Pie as a coffe shop and not just a dessert place. The other 2 coffee shops had longer lines so I walked down Park Ave to this place. In the beverage department there are coffees, teas and hot choc. Coffee here is just as good but the pastries are way better here. Besides pies there are other pastries. There are also meat pies if you want to make a meal out of it. The interior is newer and has a cleaner look and feel than some of the other places nearby. I had the salted caramel pie which I rate an 8 out of 10. This was my first visit. I recommend coming here first for coffee.
Submitted by Steve H on 04/23/2022
Kimbely Campbell 4 stars rating.
Found this place online decided to swing by randomly after a trip to the airport. There's some construction down there so parking is tight. Don't try and be slick and park illegally because parking enforcement is all up and down that street.
This place is super cute clean everyone is so nice They have a cute space to dine in. You can get take out and they have frozen takeaway.
I got Classic Chicken, Hog& Cheese, and Steak & Ale. I also got a sausage roll It's going down. They also have a selection of hot and cold drinks as well as teas and coffees.
Masks are required... Update after I try..
Submitted by Kimbely Campbell on 01/27/2022
Nick Smith 5 stars rating.
Amazing Pot Pies, so many fantastic flavors including veggie only (with scrumptious mushrooms and brussel sprouts). I go all the time and they are always awesome. The pies are super and they even serve beer, wine, coffee, tea too! The neighborhood is nice, parking is usually convenient. Take your doggie, they are always welcome! The staff is really great, get your enjoyable, filling, pot pies at Pops!
Submitted by Nick Smith on 01/01/2022
Ali Kurtz 3 stars rating.
Ordered a slice of the veggie quiche and key lime pie. I would not recommend the quiche, mushrooms were too chewy for personal taste. Overall kinda dry and small slice for $7. Not a fan of the crust on either slice. Key lime pie filling and whip was delicious but again something about this bland crust doesn’t do it for me. Call in order was filled within timely manner, they were busy for late lunch hour and packed up order a few minutes after I arrived.
Submitted by Ali Kurtz on 12/31/2021
