Gotham Pizza Reviews
Submitted by James Davis on 02/17/2021
James Davis 5 stars rating.
Gotham Pizza offers two different styles of pizza. The first is a thin crust New York style pizza which I haven't tried yet but looks good. They refer to the second as a Sicilian style pizza which has a thicker crust but not a deep dish. I ordered a 12" Sicilian " The Works" pizza and it was delicious! The crust was good and the toppings were very fresh as you can tell by the attached photos.
Update:
I ordered from Gotham Pizza again and got "The Works" but this time went with the New York style and again it was amazing.
Jessica Palmer 4 stars rating.
Small little pizza place. Unfortunately the interior was a bit of a letdown since it's named Gotham pizza. The waitress was busy on her phone and we sat down to dine in but ended up getting our pizza to-go and eating in the car. We got a 16" cheese and it was really good!
Submitted by Jessica Palmer on 09/01/2022
Aileen Carney 1 stars rating.
Went to pick up my order I placed online and when I got there the person working upfront Larissa went to the back to get it came back to the front went back again and then told me the it would be about 15 minutes. I asked her was it ever made and then she told me it was never made because the cook left. This was a big waste of my time. I know this stuff happens at times but they could have been more observant of what was going on with the employees working.
Submitted by Aileen Carney on 08/14/2022
Shinoratto 4 stars rating.
Really good pizza! The interior was kinda ghetto but it doesn't really matter because the pizza was very cheesy and just good! The Mozzarella sticks were mediocre but I came there for the pizza and the definitely delivered!
Submitted by Shinoratto on 08/12/2022
Blake Pryor 3 stars rating.
I may have just ordered wrong but I was not a fan of the Sicilian style pizza. The bread was super thick and kind of dry for me. Again, that may be exactly how it should be and I just don’t like it. Roping were all very good though and the staff was very friendly. Looks like that have some good lunch deals and pizza y the lice that did look very tasty. I will give it another shot and adjust my review if the other pizza is a lot better.
Submitted by Blake Pryor on 07/05/2022
Curtis Palmer 4 stars rating.
Ohh it was great quiet lil spot,the pizza I had was huge and delicious to be thin sliced
Submitted by Curtis Palmer on 06/04/2022
NC Craven 5 stars rating.
Great pizza very helpful at the front while ordering.
Submitted by Nc Craven on 05/28/2022
Roderica Smith 5 stars rating.
Great pizza place with fresh ingredients made to order! Giant slice of pizza!
Submitted by Roderica Smith on 03/26/2022
N D von Biedenfeld 3 stars rating.
First time visiting. Service was great. The waiter was attentive. We had one order of mozzarella sticks with marinara for an appetizer. They were good but warm not hot. We also shared a large chef salad and a 16" pizza. We were undecided about what type of pizza to get; the waiter told us they could do half & half; so, we did. It was New York style pizza ... large, wide slices, and thin crust. Over all the pizza was good, food presentation was aesthetically pleasing, and the service was great.
Submitted by N D Von Biedenfeld on 03/18/2022
Relii Cabrales 4 stars rating.
Grungy looking place but the food is bomb! Especially when you are just getting out of the bar and craving some pizza. The prices are a little high but they deserve it since they are open until 3am! Right now due to Covid they are not letting people eat inside, so that was a bummer but it's all good. The menu has a lot to choose from and the wait wasn't that bad.
Submitted by Relii Cabrales on 05/04/2021
