Tonys Di Napoli
Company Details
Tuesday: 11:30AM-11PM
Wednesday: 11:30AM-11PM
Thursday: 11:30AM-11PM
Friday: 11:30AM-11PM
Saturday: 11:30AM-11PM
Sunday: 11:30AM-10PM
Contact Information
New York, New York, 10036
United States
Tonys Di Napoli Reviews
Submitted by Matthew Trimas on 07/14/2022
Matthew Trimas 5 stars rating.
Honestly this place has stolen my heart and can keep it forever. The food here is stellar! The fettucini Alfredo is the very best I have ever had! The calamari is great, the chicken marsala is good. The raviolis were just OK however. Nothing special tasting about it. If you get the Alfredo, ask for extra sauce trust me!
I will update with a photo of our group meal because all portions here are family sized so 1 order can feed 2-3 people depending how hungry you are. We had 7 and we split 3 entrees with leftovers still.
The deserts also come family style as you can see and it's RIDICULOUSLY HUGE! Totally worth it though. Definitely come to Tony's please please do it!
Submitted by Scott Griest on 05/30/2022
Scott Griest 4 stars rating.
Family of four visited for dinner before a Broadway show. First off reservations are a must as the place was packed. Old school vibe that is hustling and bustling. Mix of locals and tourists.
For dinner they only serve full family style portions so you can’t order half portions like you can for lunch. Three of us split a Caesar salad, fettuccine Alfredo and their signature dish, chicken parmigiana.
Overall the food was solid with the chicken being the star of the show. Service good and friendly and our water glasses never empty. Prices reasonable for NYC. Will return again with a big group.
Submitted by Nancy Ng on 05/05/2022
Nancy Ng 5 stars rating.
Food was delicious and portions were huge. Hostess was very nice and was able to accommodate us even though we arrived earlier than our reservation (we just came from matinee show). Our server, Denny, was very courteous and friendly. Great experience and delicious meal! Would definitely return.
Submitted by Lee Downton on 05/02/2022
Lee Downton 5 stars rating.
We found this place through Google reviews and it didn't disappoint.
The restaurant had a lovely Italian family feel to it with friendly welcoming staff who were very attentive.
The food came out very fast and was in big portions, we were advised just to have two plates by our waiter as the dishes are meant to be shared so did as advised for 3 of us........my god!! When the food came out, it was a humongous size portion and glad we didn't or separate dishes each as 3 of struggled to eat 2 plates.........we will definitely visit again when we return to N.Y
Submitted by Katie Ferguson on 04/17/2022
Katie Ferguson 5 stars rating.
Went there bc they had good reviews and now I know why. The atmosphere was great and the food was amazing. We got a half of the chicken parmigiana and it was more like a full plate. Everything was great! There was a waiter that sang opera which just added to the whole vibe. Ben our bartender was beyond amazing and thank you for a wonderful evening!
Submitted by Wil Michael on 04/17/2022
Wil Michael 5 stars rating.
A lovely experience and delicious dinner. The atmosphere is very fun with the giant menus all over the walls. The dishes are large and the servers are great! Would recommend sharing dishes but you really can't go wrong with what you get. Delicious mountain of tiramisu.
Submitted by Shami Reshtik on 03/27/2022
Shami Reshtik 5 stars rating.
Excellent restautant.
Very large portions!! Cooked very well, great taste. We especially liked the cream-tomato-vodka pasta.
Server was very nice and attentive.
Overall this is an excellent value at this location.
Submitted by Shah Momin on 01/15/2022
Shah Momin 5 stars rating.
Almost every aspect of the meal was perfect! The service we received was fantastic, both with the great wait staff and the overall speed from ordering to eating. The vibe of the restaurant was exactly what we were hoping for as well, as it gave us a big and loud family dinner kind of experience.
All three of our main courses were delicious and worked out great as we ordered different meat options for each. The Shrimp Fra Diavolo with linguini, the Chicken Parmagiana, and the Ravioli Bolognese were all amazing. The only knock on the dishes were that they came out a little closer to warm than piping hot, especially considering how little time we waited to get them after ordering. We also ordered a side of meatballs which were also very tasty.
Besides the temperature issue, the entire meal was definitely one I would love to repeat.
Submitted by Nicole Mizzi on 12/29/2021
Nicole Mizzi 4 stars rating.
Food was decent, very big portions which is great. Very busy restaurant so reservations are a must. Must have proof of covid vaccine to dine here also. They have plastic dividers up between tables which is great and staff wearing masks. Fast service and friendly staff.
Submitted by R B on 12/28/2021
R B 5 stars rating.
Amazing experience. It's located perfectly in the heart of everything. It looked small from the outside but it was huge on the inside with different levels of seating. It was Saturday evening busy but the staff was amazingly quick, welcoming and very attentive!!! This meal that was big enough to share was one of the best I've had. Thanks for the great dining experience while we were in NY.
